News
Public procurements: the attribution of a score only may not satisfy the obligation of motivation
- 25/06/2018
By Judgment no. 3301 of 1st June 2018, the “Consiglio di Stato” has stated that, in a pairwise comparison, the motivation of an award can be satisfied by a simple score provided that the contract notice contains criteria which enable to clearly understand the connection between that score and the evaluation.
In the case at issue, each of the four evaluation parameters was made of multiple criteria, which were not given a specific importance in the determination of the final score.
Therefore, the “Consiglio di Stato” has ruled that the attribution of scores was not sufficient in order to satisfy the obligation of motivation.
NEWS
The Contracting Authority enjoys wide discretion in the evaluation of technical offers
18/04/2024The Council of State, section V, in its judgement of 27 February 2024, no. 1911, rendered on the subject of tenders, reaffirmed that "the evaluation of the tenders and, likewise, the awarding of sc...
- 15/04/2024
The Court of Cassation, in its judgement of 20 March 2024, no. 7329, rendered in banking matters, ruled that "in bank account agreements, the statement of account balance has evidentiary effectiven...
- 14/03/2024
The Court of Cassation, in its Order No. 34889 of 13.12.2023, ruled that banking or financing contracts that refer to a manipulated Euribor rate through a restrictive agreement by credit instituti...
